I accidentally sent my own property back to you, what should I do?

To notify us that you returned your personal property in one of our rental sleeves,

Go to Report A Shipping Problem

Select the game sleeve your disc is in and the option: I sent back the wrong title

If you need another shipping envelope to return your GameFly rental,

Go to Report A Shipping Problem

Select the title you would like to return and the option: I lost the disc's shipping envelope

GameFly will make a reasonable effort to return any non-GameFly property it receives. In addition, once we receive the notification of the wrong item shipped back to us, we will reach out directly.